Showing posts with label Indiana Civil Protection Order Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indiana Civil Protection Order Act. Show all posts

Friday, July 21, 2017

Prosecuting Domestic Violence against children: Two recent Lebanon Indiana cases

Domestic Violence is a crime that falls into a special class based upon an uncommon dynamic between the perpetrator and target. Similarly, there are criminal or ethical violations which receive special consequences when the relationship is between a medical provider and patient or school teacher and student. This is because offenses within the confines of these relationships are a breach of trust and the parties have accepted responsibility of the relationship roles.

When a perpetrator targets or uses his or her child in a violent manner to achieve the ends of a Domestic Violence agenda then that crime should be dealt with in the harshest manner. Two Domestic Violence cases which occurred in Lebanon, Indiana in this month exemplify this point.

On 17 July 2017 Fox 59 News reported that a Lebanon man is facing two felony counts of domestic battery for allegedly striking his wife and son.

The wife complained that on 10 July her husband struck the boy twice with a charging cord to an electronic device and then began hitting and kicking her when she intervened to protect the child. She said that this was the most recent event of her husband's physical abuse toward her and their son which has been ongoing for multiple years.

This incident was apparently prompted by the child, who is age 3, wanting to play with his tablet which was not charged. The boy was told that he couldn't because it was being charged. That is when he expressed his impatience by getting upset and pulling the charging cord from a wall.

This apparently enraged the husband who, according to court documents, “became angry and took the charger from (the boy’s) hands and then struck (the boy) twice,” as if it were a whip. He then directed his attack toward the wife by hitting and kicking her.

The wife indicated that she never contacted police because her husband threatened to take the child and leave for Mexico, and she would never see him again.

You likely didn't hear the story of a similar incident which occurred on 15 July 2017 which was allegedly perpetrated by a Lebanon woman.

That involved Elissa Summers, the embryonic host and birth parent to a boy who is eight months of age, allegedly attempting to physically attack the child's father in the child's presence at their home and harming the child during that attempt.

Her first attack of the day occurred away from the residence when she repeatedly struck Father in the back as witnesses looked on and encouraged her to stop the assault. The subsequent incident occurred at Father's house where he cohabited with Ms. Summers.

This happened as a Lebanon City Police Department officer was attempting to get a statement from her in regards to the earlier attack. When Father arrived home Ms. Summers became enraged and spewed forth a verbal tirade laced with obscenities toward Father and another resident. As witnesses looked on she tried to push her way past the officer.

According to witnesses I spoke with, as she was being restrained by the officer she threw the baby to the ground, apparently to divert the officer's attention by having him check on the welfare of the infant. As Ms. Summers attempted to again physically attack Father the officer attempted to restrain her. She then battered the officer who called for back-up and she was subsequently placed under arrest. This was not before she snatched the baby off the ground, fled into the house and proceeded to destroy items for use by the baby along with smashing jars of baby food against the walls.

At this time she is being held in the Boone County Jail without bond. A Domestic Violence Protective Order has been issued on behalf of Father. Additionally, the prosecutor has issued a No Contact Order against Ms. Summers on behalf of the baby and Father.

It was not uncommon for police to be at the residence as there had been three previous police responses in the recent past upon her request. There was an open CHiNS case at the time of this latest incident based upon an allegation Ms. Summers made against Father two weeks earlier. However, that allegation was determined to be unsubstantiated when a Lebanon City Police Department officer heard one of Ms. Summers older children make a statement contradicting what he said while in her presence. After further investigation it was determined that Ms. Summers had coached the children to lie.

The Boone County Department of Child Services has placed the boy with his father and is recommending that Ms. Summers parental rights be terminated along with the two older children she has by a different father. The Termination of Parental Rights proceedings will be quite familiar to her as she has already lost custody of four other children in four previous actions.

These incidents both convey the severity and trauma of Domestic Violence. Here, it is the use of children and infliction of physical harm toward them to coerce a trusting target into complying with the desired objectives of the perpetrators.

This is a crime that has victims. People are harmed both physically and psychologically. This is not a status offense such as those proscribed in the marijuana trade where no victim exists. Consequently, society would be better served by resources being devoted toward remediation of Domestic Violence offenders.

That young boy learned to defy his mother and yank the charging cord out of the outlet from someone near him. He also learned that when someone doesn't do as you wish then the appropriate response is to physically attack that person. In both incidents violence was directed toward small children. I have previously written about violent parents in Societal Acceptance of Domestic Violence Against the Most Vulnerable.

I am not an advocate of punishments. I find that case specific consequences are more effective that static punishments. In these cases both perpetrators should face jury trials. The common fare of plea bargains to probation is not appropriate. Society benefits by the jurors personal exposure as well as the potential media coverage. The perpetrators are forced to confront their actions and must attempt to defend against what has no defense.

If convicted they are under the coercive control of the court as well as Child Protective Services. They should be removed from the environment in which they caused the harm and the people whom they harmed. These restrictions should remain in place until such time, if ever, that they can demonstrate a high likelihood that a similar offense would not occur again. Violation of those conditions may warrant incarceration or termination of parental rights.

I have expressed these sentiments to our county prosecutor. The next step is up to him. These alleged offenders may face a jury or these alleged perpetrators can be told it's no worse than speeding; pay a little money to the state and all is well.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Make a suggestion for me to write about.


Parents who would like to achieve the best outcome for their children in a contested child custody case should visit my website and contact my scheduler to make an appointment to meet with me. Attorneys may request a free consultation to learn how I can maximize their advocacy for their clients.

Connect with me for the latest Indiana child custody related policy considerations, findings, court rulings and discussions.

View Stuart Showalter's profile on LinkedIn



Subscribe to my child custody updates

* indicates required
©2008, 2014 Stuart Showalter, LLC. Permission is granted to all non-commercial entities to reproduce this article in it's entirety with credit given.

StuartShowalter.com

Monday, June 12, 2017

Spurious claims, accepting responsibility, and high conflict child custody cases

When I encounter a parental archetype that relates to child custody, especially who not to be, I endeavor to share anecdotal accounts so you may contemplate the outcome of his or her experience. By not having to learn from personal experience but, instead, by example you and your children may benefit from those shortcomings of others.

For this latest example it is helpful that you have a working understanding of the personality of this character. I will first provide an account of the encounter and then a situation that should encapsulate the psychological make-up of the parent.

Midday Friday I set up camp with a book buyer in the parking of a book distributor who was having a sale the next day. Of the thousands of people who attend we managed to be first in line. That evening we were joined by some of the ten other people he employs to assist him. That evening during the course of general conversation a man so employed mentioned something to the effect of gender bias in the application of Indiana's Civil Protection Order Act.[en1]

His claims ran the usual gamut of long ago dispelled notions. This included that the DVPO was unconstitutional, that it transferred property without hearing or due process, that the exclusion of an owner of property from the real property was the criminal act of conversion[en2] , that men are ordered to pay child support -- even if they go to prison -- and can't get out of it, that women never have to pay child support, and, of course, that parenting time should be 50/50 and deviations from that are an unconstitutional abrogation of a father's rights. The claim that the 13th Amendment was unconstitutional and we don't legally have to pay federal income tax was probably in there too.

My arguments to the contrary were met with broad disputations not on point to my claim but rather generalized to a constitutional argument such as the "general welfare" clause[en3] or that the "corrupt courts" were biased against fathers.

Two things occurred to me at this point. The first being that it was highly probable that he has not watched child custody or DVPO proceedings in at least 50 different courts throughout Indiana. Secondly, and more notably, this is the guy to which the book seller has occasionally mentioned over the past three or more years as a friend who is "going through a horrible custody battle" and could use my assistance.

At this point I should have painted a clear image in your head of this person. The one who broods about his situation, attributes fault to others, and may post on Facebook ad nausea about his case. It's a personality trait which is considered a deficiency in the wellness schema for fit parenting.

Here is how the book sale goes. We go into a pen that houses a grid of about 200 crates containing 500 or so books each. Our group spreads out in a preplanned course in pairs or trios. There is a picker, such as me, who decides which books to purchase. Then there is a packer who receives the books or is told to pull them from the bins. This person or another may act as a runner who takes the books to a check-out area and then returns with another empty packing box.

The particular parent who is the subject of this posting mostly acts as a picker but floats as needed. After accumulating about 2000 books [80 boxes] we were done and all proceeded to check-out. Well not quite all. One person wasn't there.

During the frantic rush as we pour over these books each of us comes across a few titles that we want for ourselves. For efficiency those get tossed in with the books for the book seller. Well, instead of being at check-out with the others, someone was off at a staging area sorting through about 10 boxes which had not been taken to checkout to be tabulated.

While nine employees stood by idly the book seller complained to me that he needs to get those 10 boxes to check-out and we will sort through them at the shop. So I go tell our dear protagonist to get the boxes to check-out so we can get going. Further, that he will be able to retrieve his titles at the shop when we sort them there.

The response to me was simply put, "No, I am not going to do that. That doesn't work for me. You can just wait, I am going to get my books out here." The result is that the book seller is paying 10 employees an hourly wage for the time this guy picks out his books.

Well, I have never been to a hearing involving this guy. I have never seen the custody order, the petitions, or the CCS. I don't even know who the mother is or anything about her. I haven't been contacted by him for his necessary counseling.

But there is one thing I do know about the case. That this custody case, which began in the womb, continues to this day because he insists that it do so.

At this point, if you have observed my previous admonitions, you can imagine the proceedings and identify the major contributing factor to the ongoing high conflict. This man is a child parading as a parent who when he doesn't get his way is going to take his toys and go home. But the "toy" in this case is a child under the jurisdiction of the court. What that means is that court procedure is applied and done so [or supposed to be] according to statute and applicable case law.

It is the absence of a judicial officer conducting the proceedings according to statute and applicable case law -- as is supposed to be the case -- which perpetuates the conflict. That is the perception of this father as I have observed. However, his position that the general welfare clause is applicable to protection orders and that he hadn't heard of Lambert v Lambert[en4] relating to child support payments being reduced for incarcerated parents demonstrates his misapplication, misunderstanding or ignorance of law.

What doesn't go over well in these proceedings is the proposition that the judicial officer is a conspirator in a vast anti-father scheme, that there is a constitutional mandate to order 50/50 parenting time, that the court acts criminally, and that this is not a matter for a court to decide. All made without supporting evidence or historic reference.

The reason I long ago expanded from providing just trial strategy assistance and appellate preservation to providing cognitive behavioural therapy directed toward child custody proceedings in because underlying perceptions direct behaviour. That is, you act according to your thoughts.

If an argument is to be made in court regarding the custody or parenting time of a child then it should be valid and comport to established procedure and law. Courts are a venue for logic and law to be applied. Thinking otherwise is the foundation for behaviours destructive to a case. Philosophical arguments to the contrary should be saved for another venue like the legislature, academia or less formal popular culture. And while on the subject of philosophy our protagonist may be well advised to examine Heidegger's proposition that we are engaged in the world.

notes
1] IC 24-26-5 et seq
2] IC 35-43-4-3 A person who knowingly or intentionally exerts unauthorized control over property of another person commits criminal conversion, a Class A misdemeanor.
3] Article I, section 8 of the U. S. Constitution grants Congress the power to "lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts, and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common defense and general Welfare of the United States."
4]  Lambert v. Lambert,. 801 N.E. 2d 1176, 1180 (IN. 2007) Prior to Lambert, Indiana was one of the states that held the position that commission of a crime was a voluntary act which resulted in imprisonment and as such was voluntary underemployment. Thus, support payment orders should not be modified to reflect the reduced earnings during incarceration. The Lambert decision held that the decision to commit a crime was so far removed from intent to get child support reduced that it was therefore improper to base child support payments on anything other than current incarceration income.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Make a suggestion for me to write about.


Parents who would like to achieve the best outcome for their children in a contested child custody case should visit my website and contact my scheduler to make an appointment to meet with me. Attorneys may request a free consultation to learn how I can maximize their advocacy for their clients.

Connect with me for the latest Indiana child custody related policy considerations, findings, court rulings and discussions.

View Stuart Showalter's profile on LinkedIn



Subscribe to my child custody updates

* indicates required
©2008, 2014 Stuart Showalter, LLC. Permission is granted to all non-commercial entities to reproduce this article in it's entirety with credit given.

StuartShowalter.com

Monday, March 30, 2015

Res Judicata in a Domestic Violence Protection Order [DVPO] Indiana opinion and its application to Child Custody Modification - Abuse of Civil Protection Order Act

A Domestic Violence Protection Order [DVPO] will not stop someone who intends to harm the person I refer to as the targeted individual rather than protected person as courts often do.[en1] However, it is a law enforcement tool that may allow for interdiction of the potential perpetrator which would not otherwise be legally possible. It also inhibits the respondent’s liberty whether he or she is a likely perpetrator of Domestic Violence. It is for this reason that it is imperative that a DVPO only be properly granted. The Indiana Court of Appeals has succinctly reasoned why this caution must be observed;
”[A]t the state level, violation of the trial court’s protective order is punishable by confinement in jail, prison, and/or fine. Furthermore, after the trial court has issued a protective order, it is a federal offense for a respondent to purchase, receive, or possess a firearm if the protected person is his current or former spouse, a current or former significant other, or a person with whom the respondent has a child. Thus, an improperly granted protective order may pose a considerable threat to the respondent’s liberty.”[en2] [emphasis added][en3]

Vacating the Domestic Violence Protective Order
The Indiana Court of Appeals on 26 March 2015 rendered an opinion in A.A. v A.S. heard by Judge Calvin D Hawkins in the Lake County Superior Court. The DVPO case arose from the parties’ marriage. Their marriage was dissolved on 24 September 2013. Strategically, on the same day, A.S. filed a DVPO petition [“2013 Petition”] against A.A. alleging that A.A. had committed multiple acts of Domestic Violence and stalking against A.S. in 2012. The trial court granted an emergency ex parte order for protection.[en4] On 22 October 2013, the trial court dismissed the petition due to A.S.’s failure to show that Domestic Violence had occurred by a preponderance of the evidence. That should have ended the litigation on that issue.

However, on 04 June 2014, A.S. again petitioned [“2014 Petition”] for a DVPO against A.A and appeared pro se at an ex parte hearing in front of Judge Hawkins. The trial court granted an ex parte order for protection and set a hearing on the motion. On 03 July 2014, A.A., within the time limit prescribed by statute[en5], filed a motion to dismiss 2014 Petition. Judge Hawkins denied the motion to dismiss at the outset of the 28 August 2014 hearing. At the hearing, A.S. recounted many incidents of domestic abuse which occurred prior to filing 2013 Petition. The last Domestic Violence incident was alleged by A. S. to have occurred in January of 2013. When asked by counsel if there had been any incidents following 2013 Petition A.S. responded, “No, but I don’t want any more to happen.” The trial court then found that Domestic or Family Violence had occurred sufficient to justify the issuance of a DVPO, that A.A. represented a credible threat to the safety of a A.S., and that granting to A.S. a one-year protective order against A.A. was necessary to bring about a cessation of the violence or the threat of violence.[en6]

A.A. appealed citing the doctrine of res judicata.[en7] A.S. argued that the matter wasn’t settled because the dismissal of 2013 Petition was not rendered “on the merits,” as is required by the second element of the res judicata doctrine. However, the order dismissing 2013 Petition states, “The Petitioner has not shown, by a preponderance of the evidence, that domestic or family violence, stalking, or a sex offense has occurred sufficient to justify the issuance of an Order for Protection.” Clearly there was a hearing, evidence was presented, witnesses heard, and a judgment rendered on the merits. Accordingly, A.S. was barred from attempting to gain a subsequent DVPO based on any allegations of Domestic Violence prior to that previous hearing in 2013. Res judicata exists because it prevents dissatisfied litigants, like A.S., from seeking to get a different judge to hear the same matter. Trying to re-litigate before a different judge is called forum shopping. The doctrine of res judicata brings finality to litigation and reduces redundant litigation by not permitting parties who had been denied relief to re-petition in different courts.

The panel in reversing Judge Hawkins reasoned, “[t]he trial court was precluded, under the doctrine of res judicata, from granting a protective order based on incidents that occurred prior to [the previous hearing], and there were no alleged incidents of misconduct which occurred after that [hearing]. Therefore, the trial court’s grant of the order for protection was clearly erroneous.”

Res judicata
The doctrine of res judicata prevents the relitigation of a matter already adjudicated. This is the basis for the prohibition in child custody modification hearings on the submission of evidence relating to that which occurred prior to the last date that evidence was submitted in the previous custody hearing.[en8] There are however exceptions to this rule[en9] which I will not go into here but can develop in individual cases as those exceptions are fact specific. Res judicata applies when the same matter is brought before the court which had already been ruled upon and settled.

Res judicata serves the purpose of judicial economy. This rule is intended to bar the relitigation of a matter already brought to finality. That is, when a court of competent jurisdiction, including an appellate court or the underlying court on remand, has entered a final order as to the parties on a claim, demand, or cause of action the parties or their privies may not bring the same claim, demand, or cause of action to the court again.

Child Custody/Parenting Time Modification
To seek a change in child custody or parenting time orders Indiana has codified the requirements that must be met for an order to be modified.[en10] All other states have similarly done so. The purpose of this is the presumption that “permanence and stability are considered best for the child’s welfare and happiness.”[en11]

Therefore, the procedural hurdle which has been established that must be overcome is twofold; 1] there must be a substantial change in one of the enumerated factors provided for in statute, and 2] the modification must be in the best interest of the child.[en12] The modification statute provides that the court is not to consider evidence preceding the last custody hearing.[en13] There are exceptions though. It is the failure of practitioners and parents to understand the exceptions that lead to the mistaken belief that events prior to the previous hearing are off limits. The doctrine of res judicata, and more likely in child custody case collateral estoppel[en14], is not an absolute bar to presenting evidence from a prior child custody hearing. The Court of Appeals has held that it is well within the discretion of the trial court to hear prior evidence stating that prior evidence of “past behaviour was a valid predictor of future conduct.”[en15] Although prior evidence may be heard the doctrine of res judicata requires, and the Court has similarly held, that the change in the factors for considering modification of custody must have occurred subsequent to the previous hearing on custody.[en16]

Conclusion
The doctrine of res judicata provides that matters previously settled may not be re-litigated. In the case examined here it was the denial of a petition for a DVPO and, as I have explained, it is also applicable to child custody and parenting time matters. Incidents of Domestic Violence occurring prior to a previous hearing or decision may not be properly admitted unless for the purpose of demonstrating a pattern of behaviour relevant to a cause of action arising subsequent to the prior court action. In the immediate case the Court correctly applied res judicata because the matter had been settled when a prior court dismissed the claim and no new allegations had arisen.

Child custody matters however are not fully settled until the child has been emancipated. For purposes of res judicata child custody matters are resolved until there has been a substantial change in at least one of the essential factors for determining custody and parenting time. Events prior to the previous submission of evidence may be considered relevant, and appropriately admitted, so long as such evidence is connected to the change occurring following the previous submission of evidence.

Notes
[1] I avoid use of the term “protected person” because I feel that it can give the target of Domestic Violence a false sense of security in that he or she is now protected. It is still incumbent upon any person to be vigilant in providing for his or her own security regardless of any Domestic Violence issues.
[2] Barger v Barger, 887 N.E. 2d 990, 993-94 (Ind. Ct. App. 2008) (internal citations omitted)
[3] I note that the Court of Appeals uses the pronoun “him” in the example when referring to someone who is the respondent in a DVPO as a means to demonstrate the ubiquity of which abuser is used synonymous with males although perpetrators are about equally divided by gender.
[4] Indiana Code section IC 34-26-5-9(a)(1) provides that if it appears from a petition for an order for protection or from a petition to modify an order for protection that domestic or family violence has occurred or that a modification of an order for protection is required, a court may, without notice or hearing, immediately issue an order for protection ex parte or modify an order for protection ex parte.
[5] Indiana Code section 34-26-5-10(a) provides that if a court issues an order for protection ex parte or a modification of an order for protection ex parte and enjoins the Respondent from performing certain acts then, upon a request by either party not more than thirty days after service of the order or modification, the court shall set a date for a hearing on the petition. The hearing must be held not more than thirty days after the request for a hearing is filed unless continued by the court for good cause shown.
[6] Indiana Code section 34-26-5-9 provides: A finding that domestic or family violence has occurred sufficient to justify the issuance of an order under this section means that a respondent represents a credible threat to the safety of a petitioner or a member of a petitioner’s household. Upon a showing of domestic or family violence by a preponderance of the evidence, the court shall grant relief necessary to bring about a cessation of the violence or the threat of violence.
[7] The doctrine of res judicata bars the litigation of a claim after a final judgment has been rendered in a prior action involving the same claim between the same parties or their privies. Small v. Centocor, Inc., 731 N.E.2d 22, 26 (Ind. Ct. App. 2000), reh’g denied, trans. denied. The principle behind this doctrine, as well as the doctrine of collateral estoppel, is the prevention of repetitive litigation of the same dispute. Id. The following four requirements must be satisfied for a claim to be precluded under the doctrine of res judicata: 1) the former judgment must have been rendered by a court of competent jurisdiction; 2) the former judgment must have been rendered on the merits; 3) the matter now in issue was, or could have been, determined in the prior action; and 4) the controversy adjudicated in the former action must have been between the parties to the present suit or their privies. Id. MicroVote Gen. Corp. v. Indiana Election Comm’n, 924 N.E.2d 184, 191 (Ind. Ct. App. 2010).
[8] Indiana Code 31-17-2-21[c] provides that “[t]he court shall not hear evidence on a matter occurring before the last custody proceeding between the parties unless the matter relates to a change in the factors relating the the best interest of the child as described by section 8 and, if applicable, section 8.5 of this chapter.”
[9] Indiana Code Section 31-14-13-9 provides: In a proceeding for a custody modification, the court may not hear evidence on a matter occurring before the last custody proceeding between the parties unless the matter relates to a change in the factors relating to the best interests of the child as described in section 2, and if applicable, section 2.5 of this chapter. [emphasis added]
If a party raises a previously litigated issue or fails to object when it is raised then that party cannot later claim error. “A timely objection is a prerequisite to appellate review,” Werner v. Werner, 946 N.E.2d 1233, 1246 (Ind. Ct. App. 2011) (quoting Trout v. Trout, 638 N.E.2d 1306, 1397 (Ind. Ct. App. 1994), trans. denied), trans. denied.
[10] Modification of custody and parenting time is controlled by Indiana Code 31-17-2-21
[11] Lamb v Wenning, 600 N.E. 2d 96, 97 (Ind. 1992)
[12] Indiana Code 31-17-2-21 at [a]
[13] Id at [c]
[14] The collateral estoppel doctrine states that a prior judgment between the same parties on a different cause of action may not be re-litigated as to the issues in controversy upon which the finding or judgment was rendered. When an issue of ultimate fact has been determined by a valid judgment, that issue cannot be again litigated between the same parties in future litigation.
[15] Arms v Arms, 803 N.E. 2d 1201, 1209 (Ind. Ct. App. 2004) (evidence from prior hearing was just as relevant to instant hearing, as past behaviour was a valid predictor of future conduct.)
[16] Wolljung v Sidell, 891 N.E. 2d 1109, 1111 (Ind. Ct. App. 2009) (We note that a trial court is limited to considering changes in the factors that have occurred since the last custody decree.)
note: I propound that factors occurring “following the close of evidence” would be a more accurate standard to use considering the lapse of time which allows for the submission of proposed TR52 findings and conclusions as well as the judicial officer’s time to write and deliver the order. I have yet to find a need to make this argument at either the trial court or appellate level.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Make a suggestion for me to write about.


Parents who would like to achieve the best outcome for their children in a contested child custody case should visit my website and contact my scheduler to make an appointment to meet with me. Attorneys may request a free consultation to learn how I can maximize their advocacy for their clients.

Connect with me for the latest Indiana child custody related policy considerations, findings, court rulings and discussions.

View Stuart Showalter's profile on LinkedIn



Subscribe to my child custody updates

* indicates required
©2008, 2015 Stuart Showalter, LLC. Permission is granted to all non-commercial entities to reproduce this article in it's entirety with credit given.

StuartShowalter.com